Ma and God Shel Silverstein'God gave us fingers---Ma says, "Use your fork."God gave us voices---Ma says,"Don't scream."Ma says eat broccoli, cereal and carrots.But God gave us tasteys for maple ice cream. God gave us fingers---Ma says, "Use your hanky."God gave us puddles---Ma says, "Don't splash."Ma says, "Be quiet, your father is sleeping."But God gave us garbage can covers to crash. God gave us fingers---Ma says, "Put your gloves on."God gave us raindrops---Ma says, "Don't get wet."Ma says be careful, and don't get too near to
Those strange lovely dogs that God gave us to pet.
God gave us fingers---Ma says, "Go wash 'em."
But God gave us coal bins and nice dirty bodies.
And I ain't too smart, but there's one thing for certain---
Either Ma's wrong or else God is.
TPCASTT
T-title: When I first read the title of this poem, I predicted that this poem is going to be about the comparison between ma and God. Or maybe ma learning somthing from God.
P-paraphrase:
God gave us fingers, but mom tells the child that it is there to use your fork, to use your hanky,and to put gloves on. God gave us coal bins and nice dirty bodies, but mom tells the child to wash them. God gave us voice, but mom tells the child that not to scream and to be quiet. God gave us raindrops, but mom tells the child not to get wet. God gave us maple ice cream, but mom tells the child to eat other vegetables. God gave us puddles, but mom tells the child not to splash and go near to those strange lovely dogs that God gave us to pet. In the end, the child conlcudes that even though she/he is not smart, but she/he knows that either mom or God is wrong.
C-connotation:
"God gave us "..."---Ma says, "..." This phrase is repeating in every first line. Also each paragrph has four lines with rhythems.
A-attitude: The author is a child who is innocent and very curious. The chid knows that ma or God is wrong, but the child is not sure. The child is confused with Ma's words and God's words, however she/he knows the difference between ma and God's words.
S-shifts: The tone shifts in the last paragrph. From first to third paragrph author is talking about the difference between ma's words and God's words that she/he have heard before. In the last paragrph she/he based on the previous paragrphs.
T-title: I believe that the title represetns the realization of the difference between Ma's words and God's words.
T-theme: The theme of this poem is criticizing the world that ignores the creativity, but only admiring the fixed form. However, we should realize what God have created beautiful things for us. We should admire nature and the original form of human.
Additional thoughts after reading this poem:This poem is written by the author who wrote "The Giving Tree" I have enjoyed reading this book and luckily I have found one of his poem. This poem is criticizing the world that ignores the creativity, but only admiring the fixed form. For instance, adults gives up natural ways, insdead they admires the efficient way. These days people are only seeking for what is most fast and comfortable. However, we should realize what God have created beautiful things for us. We should admire nature and the original form of human. I have nevery realized these before until I read this poem. I truly enjoyed reading this poem. This is one of my best poem ever!